Fair Doesn’t Mean Nice

I’ve heard the phrase a thousand times:

“It’s not personal. It’s business.”

I’ve never completely understood that.

Business feels pretty personal to me. There are people on both sides, and the decisions we make affect them.

I notice this especially in real estate, where negotiation is often treated like a game. Someone wins. Someone loses.

Get every last dollar. Give up as little as possible. Use your leverage. Make the other side blink first.

I’ve never been comfortable approaching business that way.

My instinct is usually simpler:

What would be fair?

But fairness isn’t the same as being nice.

You can hold your price and still be fair. You can protect your interests, deliver bad news or walk away from a deal that doesn’t work.

Sometimes fairness requires a difficult conversation. Sometimes it means saying no. Sometimes the right decision will still disappoint someone.

Being fair doesn’t mean giving in. It means being honest about what you need without trying to take advantage of the other person.

Maybe the goal of negotiation isn’t for both sides to get everything they want.

Maybe it’s for both sides to be clear about what matters, protect their legitimate interests, and see if there’s an agreement that works reasonably well for everyone.

That may not sound like hard-nosed business.

But I’ve always believed the best agreements are the ones where neither person feels taken advantage of—and both would be willing to work together again.

You don’t have to be ruthless to be firm.

And you don’t have to make someone else lose in order to make a good deal.

—

I help entrepreneurial people think through what’s next in their work, business or ideas. If something here sparks an idea or conversation, I’d love to hear from you.